As March 1 approaches, many landlords will see new tenants farming their property. Others will face lingering disputes from last crop year. This is a good time to review several important rights and obligations of landlords and tenants under Iowa farm leases. While these rights and obligations are primarily determined by the terms of a written lease, general legal principles apply to all Iowa leases. This article addresses several issues that often arise this time of year. Those wondering about their specific legal rights should consult with an attorney. This article is not intended to provide legal advice.
My tenant and I signed a written lease for the 2016 crop year. The lease provides that the rent is due, up front, on March 1. It’s March 5 and my tenant hasn’t paid. I am afraid that he does not have the money, yet he is not willing to walk away. What can I do?
First, it is important to note that requiring rent up front is a good idea for landlords wishing to minimize disputes and problems associated with a tenant’s nonpayment of rent. Nonetheless, this protective approach does not always guarantee smooth sailing. Sometimes, a landlord will be forced to confront a nonpayment situation early on in the lease term. It remains true that working with an existing tenant and attempting to reach an amicable solution is often the best approach to handling conflicts. Even so, landlords concerned about their tenants’ ability to pay are better off confronting the problem early on, rather than letting the matter simmer and the problems compound.
Iowa Code §562.6 generally provides that a farm lease will automatically renew under the existing terms for another crop year unless the landlord serves the tenant with a written notice for termination on or before September 1. This is true even when the parties have a written lease that specifies a certain time for the lease to expire. Iowa’s laws are very protective of tenants and were written decades ago to ensure that landlords would not oust tenants without giving them adequate time to find new farms to lease.
It is important to note, however, that the written termination notice requirement does not apply where “there is default in the performance of the existing rental agreement.”[i] Failing to pay rent when it is due is a default in performance that entitles the landlord to initiate termination proceedings, no matter when that default occurs.[ii] Although many leases provide that nonpayment of rent “terminates” the lease, Iowa courts have ruled that termination in such cases is not automatic, but an option the landlord can exercise.[iii] The courts have reasoned that without this interpretation, a tenant could take advantage of his own default and unilaterally terminate a lease by refusing to pay rent.
Many written leases contain provisions specifying how a landlord must go about terminating a lease for nonpayment. Landlords should be careful not to breach such provisions. Generally, however, a landlord faced with a tenant whose rent is past due can terminate the lease. The landlord should first issue a notice of default and provide an opportunity to cure. When a tenant doesn't pay, the landlord may initiate eviction proceedings under Iowa Code chapter 648. This is an action to formally evict the tenant from the premises. The statute requires that the landlord first serve the tenant with a three-day “notice to quit.”[iv] If the tenant leaves the property after the notice to quit is served, the landlord is free to rent the premises to another tenant. If the tenant refuses to leave, the landlord may then file the “forcible entry and detainer” petition in court and personally serving the tenant with notice of the action. Once receiving the petition, the court will schedule a timely hearing to provide the parties an opportunity to be heard.[v]
I served my tenant with a written notice of termination before September 1 of last year. He argues that the notice was not valid and refuses to vacate the premises. What can I do?
A landlord may seek to oust a tenant who has improperly stayed on the land after legal termination of the lease by following the same forcible entry and detainer procedures outlined above. The landlord first serves the tenant with a three-day notice to quit and then files a forcible entry and detainer petition in court. Upon receiving the petition, the court will hold a hearing to give the tenant an opportunity to respond.
My tenant in is his first year of a three-year lease. I am not happy with the way my tenant is caring for my land. I believe that his farming practices constitute a breach of the good husbandry provisions in our written lease. What can I do?
Good husbandry provisions are important components of well-written leases. These provisions are designed to ensure that tenants are good stewards of the land they are farming. Tenants who breach these provisions may be liable for damages to their landlords. Landlords cannot assume, however, that a violation of a good husbandry provision automatically entitles the landlord to terminate the lease.
Iowa courts have ruled that tenants are entitled to notice and a reasonable opportunity to cure alleged breaches of such provisions.[vi] Termination is a harsh remedy that will not be imposed where the tenant has cured even a “material breach” of the lease. Therefore, if a landlord provides the tenant with notice of the specific ways the good husbandry provisions are being violated, the tenant will be given a reasonable period of time during which to cure the breaches. If the tenant does not cure the problems, the court will likely allow the termination. In a 1963 case, the Iowa Supreme Court allowed the landlord to terminate a multi-year lease for breach of the good husbandry provisions.[vii] The termination, however, was effective at the beginning of the following crop year. The landlord did not attempt to terminate the lease mid-year. The court noted that the same conduct by the tenant may not have justified a landlord in terminating the lease “in the middle of a crop year and ousting the tenant with the hardships and difficulties resulting from such action.”[viii] Nonetheless, the court found that the landlord “should not be required to put up with [the tenant’s poor land management practices] for two more crop years.”[ix]
Landlords or tenants facing the above situations are encouraged to consult with legal counsel. Landlords who attempt to oust a tenant improperly can be found liable to the tenant for damages for interfering with the tenant’s “quiet use and enjoyment” of the property.[x] Landlords are also reminded that the deadline for perfecting their landlord’s lien is 20 days from the date the tenant takes possession of the property. Without filing the UCC-1, the landlord has no priority over other creditors in the event of a default. For more information on the landlord’s lien, please read this blogpost: Don't Forget that Iowa Landlord's Lien.
[i] Iowa Code § 562.6.
[ii] See generally, Riggs v. Meka, 17 N.W.2d 101 (Iowa 1945).
[iii] See, e.g., Vincent v. Kaser Construction Co., 125 N.W. 2d 608 (Iowa 1963).
[iv] Iowa Code § 648.3.
[v] Iowa Code § 648.5.
[vi] See, e.g., Mart v. Mart, 824 N.W.2d 535 (Iowa Ct. App. 2012).
[vii] McElwee v. DeVault, 120 N.W.2d 451 (Iowa 1963).
[viii] Id. at 454.
[x] See, e.g., Kuiken v. Garrett, 51 N.W.2d 149 (Iowa 1952).
CALT does not provide legal advice. Any information provided on this website is not intended to be a substitute for legal services from a competent professional. CALT's work is supported by fee-based seminars and generous private gifts. Any opinions, findings, conclusions or recommendations expressed in the material contained on this website do not necessarily reflect the views of Iowa State University.